Phone: 905-940-6232    Fax: 905-940-6235
 
 
 
 
You are here - Home / Consumer Info / Toronto Star Editorials / Mike Karim Editorials

Breaking the terms of a lease must have consequences - April 12, 2008

I'm surprised by how many customers sign auto lease agreements without fully understanding the terms.

Here's a situation that occurs frequently at new-car dealerships:

A customer leases a car for, say, a four-year term. When he signs the lease agreement, the customer appears happy with the car and the terms.

Three years later, the customer decides he wants to get out of the lease early. People do this all the time for a number of reasons: family situation changes, illness, job loss, etc.

What's surprising is the reaction of some customers when they learn the financial consequences that will result from breaking the terms of their lease. They fail to recognize that they are responsible for fulfilling all of the terms of the agreement.

Let's compare the market value of a leased vehicle worth $17,565 with the payment history over a 48-month term. The monthly lease payment is $399 (including taxes).

The market value of the vehicle will decrease (steeply at first, then gradually) throughout the entire term of the lease. At every point in the 48-month term, the vehicle's value remains less than the total amount of depreciation the customer has paid.

Any attempt to terminate the lease before the 48-month mark will result in a deficit on the vehicle, for which the lessee is responsible. Obviously, the sooner the lease is terminated, the larger the deficit (hence, the more the customer will owe).

Only at the 48-month mark do the monthly payments and vehicle's market value actually meet.

We also often see customers who return leased vehicles with excessive kilometres. A standard lease agreement includes an "excessive kilometre clause," which stipulates that any kilometres over a specified number is subject to a 7- to 15-cent (on average) surcharge per kilometre.

Lease agreements can be structured to make allowances for excessive kilometres.

This will result in larger monthly payments. In other words, lessees are paying for the added depreciation up front, each month, as opposed to paying for it at the end of the lease.

The excessive kilometre clause is included in lease agreements for good reason.

When a vehicle is returned to the dealership in good condition, with the number of kilometres outlined in the agreement, then the vehicle has a certain residual value to the dealer.

If the residual value is less than what it should be because of high kilometres or inconsistent maintenance, then the lessee is responsible for any shortfall in market value.

It's no different than if you lease a computer or a photocopier. If you decide midway through the lease that you no longer want the equipment, you can't just return it to the store without any financial consequences.

There are ways to avoid paying the financial penalties, if you want to get out of an auto lease early.

For instance, you could transfer your lease to another person (friend, neighbour, family member), who would assume the obligations for the duration of the lease.

Leasing is a preferred option for thousands of Canadians each year. I would never dissuade someone from exploring leasing, if it fits his budget and driving habits.

But I strongly recommend that potential lessees do their research before signing any agreement. Make sure you understand every term and clause contained in the lease.

Understanding the terms will allow you to avoid any unpleasant surprises in the event you want to terminate a lease early.



 
 
 
 
Main   -   Used Cars   -   New Cars   -   Employment   -   Dealer Login
Copyright © 2009 T.A.D.A. Toronto Automobile Dealers Association - site designed and hosted by Capitol Technologies